Sent to the ‘Mexican school’ 75 years ago, Sylvia Mendez’s fight for equality continues

Sylvia Mendez stands in front of eighth-grade students inside a classroom in Santa Ana.
Sylvia Mendez, 85, visits an eighth-grade historical past class at Mendez Elementary Intermediate College, which is called after her mother and father Felicitas and Gonzalo Mendez.
(Gina Ferazzi / Los Angeles Occasions)

On a spring morning, Sylvia Mendez walked into an eighth-grade historical past classroom in Santa Ana and started a chat she’s given a whole bunch of instances earlier than. At 85 years outdated, she held regular with a cane.

Her voice was delicate however her message robust.

“By no means get distracted,” she advised the scholars in entrance of her. “It's a must to battle for what you need.”

Seventy-five years in the past this month, Mendez’s mother and father and 4 different Orange County households received the landmark class-action court docket case Mendez, et al. vs. Westminster College District of Orange County, permitting her to go away the uncared for “Mexican faculty” she was compelled to attend and enroll in a whites-only faculty with a phenomenal playground she nonetheless remembers with a smile.

The case helped result in the desegregation of California faculties and influenced the authorized arguments that have been utilized in Brown vs. Board of Training seven years later, when the U.S. Supreme Courtroom declared that separate faculties based mostly on race have been unconstitutional.

The Brown choice is well-known. Much less well-known is how segregationist insurance policies pushed Latino college students into substandard faculties all through the Southwest.

That's the story that, for many years, Mendez has devoted herself to telling — to make sure that the story of her mother and father’ battle will not be forgotten. She’s traveled throughout the nation to talk with college students, together with frequent stops right here, at Mendez Elementary Intermediate College. It was named for her household.

She can be keenly conscious that the battle for equal training will not be over. Faculties are nonetheless segregated, although for various causes immediately, and Latino college students are nonetheless being left behind. The inequities have solely been exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic and faculty closures.

She retains telling her story in hopes of persuading younger folks to battle for their very own training.

“I’m so pleased with you,” she repeated repeatedly to the scholars that spring morning. Then, gently, she reminded them: “Generally it’s a wrestle to get what you need. However you simply don’t hand over.”

She repeats the story of Mendez, et al. vs. Westminster for one more purpose as properly — to satisfy a promise to her mom.


Many years later, the main points stay vivid.

She was 8 years outdated when her household moved from Santa Ana to Westminster throughout World Warfare II. Her father had agreed to lease a farm belonging to Seima and Masako Munemitsu, a Japanese American household who had been compelled into an internment camp.

Mendez’s aunt tried to enroll her, her two brothers and cousins within the neighborhood faculty, seventeenth Road College, the one with a manicured garden, palm timber and the playground that Mendez nonetheless remembers.

An official advised her the cousins could be allowed to enroll. They have been honest skinned and had a French final identify. However Mendez and her youthful brothers, Gonzalo and Geronimo, have been turned away and despatched to Hoover, a Mexican faculty.”

She remembers that faculty clearly too: two shacks surrounded by grime and an electrified barbed wire fence meant to maintain the cows in a neighboring area from wandering away.

Her mom, Felicitas, who was born in Puerto Rico, and her father, Gonzalo, who was of Mexican first rate, determined to battle.

They joined 4 different households from throughout the county — the Guzman household of Santa Ana, the Palominos of Backyard Grove, the Estradas of Westminster and the Ramirez household of El Modena. Collectively, their class-action lawsuit challengedsegregation within the identify of hundreds of kids.

Together with her father centered on the case, Mendez mentioned, it fell to her mom to care for the farm and her household.

At trial, faculty officers tried to argue that the separation of scholars was based mostly on language means. However these arguments floundered, with one superintendent arguing on the stand that Mexican youngsters have been inferior in “their financial outlook, of their clothes, [and] their means to participate within the actions at school.”

In his choice, the federal court docket decide wrote that equal safety “will not be offered by furnishing in separate faculties the identical technical amenities, textbooks and programs of instruction to youngsters of Mexican ancestry which might be obtainable to the opposite public faculty youngsters no matter their ancestry. A paramount requisite within the American system of public training is social equality.”

Mendez remembers sitting within the courtroom as a baby, not understanding the authorized language.

A student walks by a display case with historic photos at Mendez Fundamental Intermediate School.
A scholar walks previous historic clippings and photographs, which chronicle the battle for training equality for Latino college students in Orange County, close to the library at Mendez Elementary Intermediate College in Santa Ana.
(Gina Ferazzi / Los Angeles Occasions)

So a few years later, as she stood within the eighth-grade historical past classroom at Mendez, a boy raised his hand and requested: “How did it really feel whenever you came upon that your mother and father have been in a battle for a lot of, many youngsters to go to highschool?”

“I didn’t even know they have been preventing for a lot of youngsters,” she mentioned. “I believed they have been simply preventing for me to get into a phenomenal faculty.”

After the plaintiffs received the case, Mendez was allowed to attend beforehand all-white faculties. There, some youngsters handled her cruelly, telling her that she didn't belong. Decadeslater, the reminiscence of 1 boy who spat “Mexican” at her as if it was a slur, nonetheless stings.

Column One

A showcase for compelling storytelling from the Los Angeles Occasions.

However there have been others who invited her to their properties and events.

Attending these faculties gave her the kind of training she couldn't have gotten on the Mexican faculty. It additionally led her to lose the power to fluently communicate Spanish, a loss she nonetheless mourns.

After commencement, she studied to grow to be a nurse and had been working for greater than 30 years when she retired to look after her dying mom.

In her ultimate months, Felicitas Mendez would regularly lament that the case she and her husband had sacrificed a lot to win was unknown.

“We’d be there on the home and she or he’d say, ‘Ay, nadie sabe de este caso. Nosotros peleamos y nadie ha dicho nada.’

“Nobody is aware of about this case. We fought and nobody speaks about it.”

Nobody is aware of about this case. We fought and nobody speaks about it.

— Felicitas Mendez to her daughter, Sylvia Mendez.

Again and again earlier than her dying, Felicitas Mendez advised her daughter, “Sylvia, somebody has to inform the story.”


After Felicitas Mendez died in 1998, Mendez, who now lives in Fullerton, started touring the nation — to elementary faculties, excessive faculties, faculty campuses — to do exactly that.

Due to her efforts and these of the households of different plaintiffs within the case, the authorized battle is extra broadly identified.

Faculties have been named for the Mendez household in California, Oklahoma and Texas. There's a Lorenzo A. Ramirez Library at Santiago Canyon Faculty in Orange.

In 2007, the U.S. Postal Service issued a commemorative stamp honoring the case. And in 2011, Mendez was honored for her work by President Obama with the Presidential Medal of Freedom, the nation’s highest civilian honor.

Nonetheless, very often the scholars she talks to have by no means heard of Mendez, et al. vs. Westminster.

In the event that they know concerning the desegregation of colleges, it’s usually within the context of Brown vs. Board of Training. Generally, they've realized about segregation solely as one thing that occurred in a faraway place, largely to Black college students,in a previous that's faraway from their everyday.

“I used to be shocked at the way it was very latest,” mentioned eighth-grader Desiree Arevalo-Gil. “I didn’t know that faculties have been simply segregated lower than 100 years in the past. It wasn’t that way back.”

Then Mendez, together with her vivid recollections, walks into the room and tells them concerning the playground, the electrified fence and the little boy who mentioned to her: “You’re a Mexican. Who mentioned you can come to this faculty?” Then he advised her to go away.

“She talks about her story in a very heartfelt method and the scholars actually connect with it,” mentioned Linn Lee, a curriculum specialist for Santa Ana Unified College District, who teaches a summer season class at which Mendez is usually a visitor speaker.

“Additionally they connect with their very own experiences immediately,” she added. “How they nonetheless typically don’t really feel utterly equal.”

Sylvia Mendez chats with a student outside a classroom at Mendez Fundamental Intermediate School.
Sylvia Mendez, proper, stops to speak with scholar Jennifer Torres, 14, at Mendez Elementary Intermediate College. Mendez visits school rooms throughout the nation to satisfy a promise to her mom to not let the landmark authorized case Mendez, et al. vs. Westminster be forgotten.
(Gina Ferazzi / Los Angeles Occasions)

As Mendez traveled the nation to inform her story, she started to see firsthand how the segregation her mother and father fought not solely endured, nevertheless it had grow to be deeply entrenched in faculties.

“I began going from metropolis to metropolis and found that a few of them have been 100% Latino or 100% African American,” she mentioned. “I believed, ‘Oh my God.’”

Even Mendez Elementary Intermediate is 99% Latino. Mendez is keenly conscious of the irony.

“Two faculties named after my household, the one in Los Angeles and Santa Ana, they each are nearly 100% Latino. What does that let you know?” she requested.

The explanations behind segregation are totally different than they have been in 1947. Latinos and different college students of shade now make up a big majority of scholars in California.

Communities all through the state are extremely segregated, reflecting an extended historical past of discriminatory housing insurance policies and the aversion of many communities to permit low-income housing. District boundaries align with these communities.

Santa Ana Unified, for instance, is 96% Latino and 85% of its college students come from low-income households. About60% of graduates final yr met the necessities to attend a public college in California.

Fifteen miles away in Laguna Seashore Unified, 12% of scholars are Latino, 11% are from low-income households and practically 80% of graduates met the necessities to attend a public college in California.

Within the years because the Mendez case, court docket selections and political ones have made it extremely troublesome to problem these realities the best way Mendez, et al. vs. Westminster challenged segregation 75 years in the past.

From Mendez’s perspective, that’s why it’s so pressing that she hold speaking to college students, hold attempting to encourage them, hold telling them: “I’m so pleased with you.”

If they will simply persevere and get an training, they will earn sufficient to maneuver into communities the place their youngsters could have higher alternatives.

“They will’t cease you from residing in Huntington Seashore. They will’t cease you from residing in Tustin or anyplace,” she mentioned. “In case you have sufficient cash you should purchase a home wherever you need. In Bel-Air. In Los Angeles. Purchase a home right here in Laguna Seashore. You should buy anyplace. And then you definitely’ll go to varsities in that space.”

Earlier than wrapping up her go to at Mendez Elementary Intermediate, Mendez defined to the scholars how she began visiting school rooms to satisfy a promise to her mom to not let the case be forgotten.

“I feel I've honored my mom,” she advised them.

She walked exterior and marveled on the campus that carries her household identify. “We’re so fortunate to have this stunning faculty,” she mentioned.

Mendez Elementary Intermediate has a big area and fashionable school rooms. Then there’s one thing you possible received’t discover at different faculties: partitions lined with getting old newspaper clips and photographs depicting her mother and father’ battle.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post